Lawyers Tell UK Government You Can’t Jail Online Pirates for 10 Years

/ 3 years ago


The UK Government, currently in consultation over a proposed revision to current copyright infringement, has been told point-blank by the British and Irish Law, Education and Technology Association (BILETA) that sending pirates to jail for 10 years – one of the government’s proposals – is “unacceptable, infeasible and unaffordable.”

The consultation, commissioned by the UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO), was public, meaning anyone with an objection to the proposals could speak up, which is exactly what BILETA did. “There is no need to change the existing law [because] legitimate means to tackle large-scale commercial online copyright infringement are not only already available, but also currently being used,” BILETA’s response read.

Mike Weatherley MP, the intellectual property adviser to the Prime Minister, initiated the consultation after he concluded that the “disparity in sentencing between online and offline crime […] sends out all the wrong messages. Until this is changed, online crime will be seen as less significant than traditional theft.”

Weatherley’s 12-page consultation document went even further, saying:

“There is no doubt that copyright infringement is serious and there is no strong case for treating online infringement any differently to physical infringement. The government believes that this change will send a clear message to rights holders and criminals that copyright infringement online will not be tolerated. This is furthermore supported by the Conservative manifesto commitment that sentencing should reflect the seriousness of the crime.”

But BILETA argues that not only is the 10-year prison sentence proposal impractical, it cannot be fairly implemented. “The system has been overcrowded every year since 1994. Whilst the capacity has been increased, there is a continuing rise in the number of people being held in prison which continues to outstrip the number of places available,” BILETA’s statement reads. “In addition to difficulties relating to jurisdiction there are practical issues when seeking to identify those who run and own large websites or services which facilitate copyright infringement on a criminal scale. To begin with, the registration procedures for websites are not sufficiently verified.”

Any UK revisions to intellectual property law, though, could become redundant anyway as the European Commission is set to propose new copyright laws that will supersede any UK law.

Thank you The Register for providing us with this information.

Topics: , , ,


By supporting eTeknix, you help us grow. And continue to bring you the latest news, reviews, and competitions. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter to keep up with the latest technology. Share your favourite articles, chat with the team and more. Also check out eTeknix YouTube, where you'll find our latest video reviews, event coverage and features in 4K!
eTeknix FacebookeTeknix TwittereTeknix Instagram

Check out our Latest Video


2 Responses to “Lawyers Tell UK Government You Can’t Jail Online Pirates for 10 Years”
  1. grumpytrooper says:

    “This is furthermore supported by the Conservative manifesto commitment that sentencing should reflect the seriousness of the crime.”

    so how come politicians don’t go to prison for fraud (expenses) which involve tens of thousands of pounds but if someone claims too much benefits they get, in some cases, custodial sentences and still have to pay everything back ??

    Why aren’t Child Molesters given longer sentences ? what this paper is saying is that it’s ok to go and commit a pretty serious crime and get a relatively minor spell of custody but if you steal digital material you can get a decade of prison time…….it seems that the UK government has no idea what the word “priorities” means.

    And while we’re on the subject of European law, that can kiss my ass aswell. I live in England not the United States of Europe….

    • hazeljblankinship says:

      ➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽➽ my schoolmate’s sister makes 81$/hour on the portable workstation…….on Sat I got a prime of the degree audi sinceobtaining a check for four216$ this most striking 4 weeks what’s more, 10 thousand last-munth . unmistakably with respect to it, this to an amazing degree is that the most stunning occupation Ive had . i genuinely started six months/past and on an especially essential level in a brief moment was making more than 87$ p/h . endeavor this site…….


Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

  • Be Social with eTeknix

  • Poll

    Do you like RGB?

    View Results