One of the most notable precursors to the release of the GTA Trilogy was the fact that Take-Two Interactive had definitely kicked things into a new gear when it came to the game’s modding community. Put simply, masses of mods were taken down amid a flurry of DMCA claims and threats of legal action. However, things were definitely taken to the next level for four such people when Take-Two Interactive issued formal legal action against them, claiming $300,000 in supposed ‘damages’.
Now, admittedly, I wouldn’t fancy Take-Two’s lawyers coming after me. Following a report via TechSpot, however, it seems that the individuals have decided to strike back. Rather than simply conceding the lawsuit, fresh information seems to suggest that they plan to fight it, and, with an argument that could possibly have a huge impact on the modding community moving forwards if they are successful!
Take-Two Interactive’s legal argument is quite a simple one. It’s their copyrighted material, and, as such, no one has the right to use it without their permission. However, following the submission of their response, the four modders in question have decided to cite ‘fair use’. An argument that might not only work in front of the right judge but could also pave the way for the modding community having, pretty much, a free hand in practically any gaming title moving forwards.
Now, what do they mean by fair use? Well, the defendants basically cite 4 (relatively) basic principles as to why their modding work qualifies:
It’s certainly a compelling argument. The problem, however, will undoubtedly lie in the legal cost of proving it. As I’m sure most of you are aware, taking legal action against someone, particularly on muddy grounds such as this, is neither easy nor cheap. Particularly so when you’re taking on a company that can afford to pump millions into their case. – If this counterargument can, however, be a success, then I hope it will be explored as far as it can because, as noted above, if this passes muster to have Take-Two Interactive’s legal case dismissed, then it would provide the whole modding community with a precedent to do what they like to improve games. Within, of course, reason.
What do you think? – Let us know in the comments!
AMD has launched (thanks Wccftech) its new Ryzen 7 8745H APU, a part of the…
MSI has announced a new BIOS update in mid-August to address stability issues with Intel’s…
Many PC models from top brands have faced security breaches due to a weak BIOS…
Ahoy, Straw Hat fans! The wait is finally over. The beloved RPG adventure, ONE PIECE…
【Wireless & 1800mAh Battery Operated】Touch lamps bedside use a rechargeable large capacity battery of 1800mAh,…
Click to open expanded view F Energy efficiency label Product Sheet Lepro GU10 LED Bulbs, Warm White…